Minimum order $25
For all online orders
Collect from store
Or Auckland-wide delivery!
All Online Orders
Limited to Auckland Region

Cookie Shop

See All
Black Forest Cookie
Black Forest Cookie
$3.50
Black Forest Cookie
Images / 1 / 2

Black Forest Cookie

$3.50

Please note: Cookies require a minimum of 24 hours notice prior to pick-up or delivery.

Dark Whittaker’s chocolate & dried berries enveloped with premium Dutch cocoa dough. Rich, moist & incredibly moreish, this cookie has a cult following.

Chocolate Chunk Cookie
Choc Chunk Cookie
$3.50
Chocolate Chunk Cookie
Images / 1 / 2

Choc Chunk Cookie

$3.50

Please note: Cookies require a minimum of 24 hours notice prior to pick-up or delivery.

Ah the classic chocolate chunk. The quintessential cookie for dunking into a glass of cold milk. But this aint yo’ usual choco chunk cookie. We believe a good choc chunk has to have high quality chocolate and lots of it. So we only use big chunks of Whittaker’s chocolate & bake it so it’s crunchy on the outside but soft & chewy on the inside.
Cinnamon Cookie
Cinnamon Cookie
$3.50
Cinnamon Cookie
Images / 1 / 2

Cinnamon Cookie

$3.50

Please note: Cookies require a minimum of 24 hours notice prior to pick-up or delivery.

The underdog of the cookie world. Whilst it may look plain, it is a staff favourite. This cookie tastes like a cinnamon donut, Easter & happiness all rolled into one. Soft, chewy and fluffy in texture, it works a treat with a cup of coffee or tea. 
Cookie Cake
Cookie Cake
from $35.00
Cookie Cake
Images / 1 / 2

Cookie Cake

$35.00

Please note: Cookie Cakes require a minimum of 48 hours notice prior to pick-up or delivery.

Three giant sized cookies stacked together with a rich Whittaker’s chocolate ganache. Choose from any of our delicious cookie flavours to make up the layers of your cake. Our most popular seller is the classic Chocolate Chunk Cookie Cake.

Small Cookie Cake: recommended for 4-6 people
Large Cookie Cake: recommended for 6-10 people

Giant Cookie
Giant Cookie
$20.00
Giant Cookie

Giant Cookie

$20.00

Please note: Cookies require a minimum of 24 hours notice prior to pick-up or delivery.

Choose any of our regular cookie flavours…only supersized! We can write a personalized message on your 24cm giant cookie.

Nutella Cookie
Nutella Cookie
$3.50
Nutella Cookie
Images / 1 / 2

Nutella Cookie

$3.50

Please note: Cookies require a minimum of 24 hours notice prior to pick-up or delivery.

If you love Nutella, you’ll love this cookie. We pipe the smooth chocolate hazelnut spread into the centre of each cookie & top it off with crunchy hazelnuts.

Oreo Marshmallow Cookie
Oreo Marshmallow Cookie
$3.50
Oreo Marshmallow Cookie
Images / 1 / 2

Oreo Marshmallow Cookie

$3.50

Please note: Cookies require a minimum of 24 hours notice prior to pick-up or delivery.

Melted marshmallow on the inside with crunchy marshmallow & crushed oreos on the outside. The cookie dough is made using premium Dutch cocoa that is produced in Holland from the finest West African Cocoa beans. It gives off a bittersweet taste & a deep rich chocolate colour.

Peanut Butter Cookie
Peanut Butter
$3.50
Peanut Butter Cookie
Images / 1 / 2

Peanut Butter

$3.50

Please note: Cookies require a minimum of 24 hours notice prior to pick-up or delivery.

Peanut Butter lovers unite. We hand-pipe peanut butter straight into the centre of the cookie and top it with rich Whittaker’s chocolate. Dunk it in cold milk & you’ve got yourself a good day.
Snickers Bar Cookie
Snickers Bar Cookie
$3.50
Snickers Bar Cookie
Images / 1 / 2

Snickers Bar Cookie

$3.50

Please note: Cookies require a minimum of 24 hours notice prior to pick-up or delivery.

We managed to shove half a Snickers Bar in this cookie to form a chewy, nougaty, caramelly, nutty and incredibly popular cookie. You won’t want to share this one so make sure you get more than one.
Store Gift Card
Store Gift Card
$10.00
Store Gift Card

Store Gift Card

$10.00

Please note: Cookies require a minimum of 24 hours notice prior to pick-up or delivery.

Shopping for someone else but not sure what to give them? Give them the gift of choice with a Moustache Milk & Cookie Bar Gift Card.

Gift cards can either be delivered by mail or picked up in store and come in a little brown Moustache envelope.

White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie
White Choc Macadamia
$3.50
White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie
Images / 1 / 2

White Choc Macadamia

$3.50

Please note: Cookies require a minimum of 24 hours notice prior to pick-up or delivery.

What separates this white chocolate macadamia cookie from the others out there is how jam-packed it is with quality ingredients. Cheap chocolate and tiny little crumbs of macadamia? Forget it. We only use wonderful Whittakers White chocolate and large macadamia halves.

A little bit about us

We’re a little milk and cookie bar with a huge passion for baking the freshest and yummiest cookies around town. You can’t make good cookies with bad ingredients. That’s the way the cookie crumbles. So here at Moustache we don’t skimp on the good stuff. We use cage-free eggs, pure NZ butter, premium Dutch cocoa and plenty of delicious Whittakers chocolate with no use of additives or preservatives.

Welcome