NYTimes.com no longer supports Internet Explorer or earlier. Please upgrade your browser.. LEARN MORE ». Sections. Home. Search. Skip to content. Skip to navigation. View mobile version. The Opinion Pages. The Scrambled States of Immigration. Email. Share. Tweet. More. Search. Subscribe Now. campaign: abTest_bar1_intl_no_hover_0515 -- creative: abTest_bar1_intl_no_hover_0515_ad -- page: www.nytimes.com/yr/mo/day/opinion/the-scrambled-states-of-immigration.html, targetedPage: www.nytimes.com/yr/mo/day/opinion, position: Bar1, keywords: nyt5,Immigration and Emigration,California,Alabama,Arizona,Obama Barack,Editorials,Law and Legislation,Illegal Immigration,Texas,States (US),has-large-lede-media,Editorial,article-medium. Log In. Settings. Close search. search sponsored by. Search NYTimes.com. Clear this text input. Go. http://nyti.ms/1MBfcys. Opinion. Op-Ed Contributor. Don’t Let Statistics Ruin Baseball. Charles M. Blow. In South Carolina, Shot in the Back as He Ran. Editorial. Israel’s Unworkable Demands on Iran. Contributing Op-Ed Writer. McDonald’s Turns ‘Progressive’. Contributing Op-Ed Writer. Will Infighting Help the Republicans in 2016?. Editorial. Can Rand Paul Win With His Principles?. Editorial. Successful Investing for the Long Haul. Taking Note. Rand Paul’s Online Blunders. Taking Note. Whatever Happened to Running as a Libertarian?. Op-Ed Contributor. Michael Bloomberg, Mayor of London?. Room for Debate. Private Profit, Public Gain?. Play Video. Op-Docs. ‘The Bull Rider’. Appreciations. Victor Gotbaum, the City’s Shop Steward. Opinionator The End. Overruling My Father. Taking Note. California’s Water Hogs. Opinionator Disunion. Lincoln’s Triumphant Visit to Richmond. Op-Ed Contributor. Can Nigeria’s Former Dictator Become a Democrat?. Op-Ed Contributor. In Nigeria, an Election to Believe In. Op-Ed Contributor. Is PBS Neglecting Its Mission?. Op-Ed Contributors. Yes, We Were Warned About Ebola. Opinionator Couch. Do You Google Your Shrink?. Opinionator Menagerie. Letting My Autistic Son Go Where the Wild Things Are. Op-Ed Contributor. Leaving Venezuela’s Fields of Dreams. Letter. The California Drought: How to Adapt. Letter. A Lawyer’s Personal Beliefs. Letter. A View From Monsanto on Herbicide Safety. Letter. Better Health Coverage. Letter. U.S. Coal Leasing Program. Taking Note. The Lessons of Rolling Stone’s ‘A Rape on Campus’. Op-Ed Contributor. China Steps Back. Editorial. The Giant of Africa Votes. Op-Ed Contributor. What Vietnam Must Now Do. Opinion. Sexually Assaulted at UVA. Taking Note. Why ‘Pro-Gay’ Makes No Sense. Opinion. The Real Reason College Tuition Costs So Much. Op-Ed Contributor. Cuba's Wildlife on Notice. Contributing Op-Ed Writer. Why Evangelicals Should Love the Pope. Contributing Op-Ed Writer. Learning Through Tinkering. Gray Matter. Our Cosmic Selves. Letters. Young, Dying and Brave. Loading.... See next articles. See previous articles. Opinion. Home Page. Home Page. World. U.S.. Politics. New York. Business. Business. Opinion. Opinion. Technology. Science. Health. Sports. Sports. Arts. Arts. Fashion & Style. Fashion & Style. Food. Food. Home & Garden. Travel. Magazine. Real Estate. Video. The Upshot. Conferences. More. The Opinion Pages. Editorial. The Scrambled States of Immigration. By. THE EDITORIAL BOARD. APRIL. Inside. Photo. Veronica Ramirez waited to apply for a New York City identification card in January.. Credit. Mark Lennihan/Associated Press. Continue reading the main story. Share This Page. Email. Share. Tweet. Save. more. Continue reading the main story. Continue reading the main story. Continue reading the main story. This story is included with an NYT Opinion subscription.. Learn more ». campaign: nyt2015_sharetools_mkt_opinion_47K78 -- creative: nyt2014_sharetools_mktg_opinion_47K78 -- page: www.nytimes.com/yr/mo/day/opinion/the-scrambled-states-of-immigration.html, targetedPage: www.nytimes.com/yr/mo/day/opinion, position: MiddleLeft. Continue reading the main story. Continue reading the main story. A country that has abandoned all efforts at creating a saner immigration policy has gotten the result it deserves: not one policy but lots of little ones, acting at cross purposes and nullifying one another. Not unity but cacophony, a national incoherence — one well illustrated in a recent. report in The Times. on the various ways the states, forsaken by Congress, are adjusting to the millions of unauthorized immigrants living outside the law.. Some, like Washington and California, allow such immigrants to earn driver’s licenses, having concluded that roads are safer when drivers are tested and insured. Other states balk at any such benefit for people they consider undeserving. They prefer to tolerate illegal driving to make a point about illegal immigration.. Twenty-six states have sued to block President Obama’s executive actions giving some immigrants work permits and protection from deportation. They argue that the actions harm them somehow, though they lack evidence, mainly because the opposite is true. A federal district judge in Texas. has sided. with the plaintiffs, blocking the Obama administration’s programs nationwide.. But states and the District of Columbia have pleaded with the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit to let the programs proceed. They understand that immigrants who are working legally and paying taxes, supporting themselves and bolstering the economy, are a benefit for all, and that the government is far better off using its limited resources deporting criminals.. Some states, notably Arizona and Alabama, have toiled mightily to thwart unauthorized immigrants at every turn, to make them miserable and unemployable. Others have decided that undocumented workers and their families are an asset to be nurtured, with benefits like more access to higher education, through in-state tuition and financial aid. They understand the reasoning of. Plyler v. Doe. the Supreme Court decision asserting all children’s right to primary schooling, and have chosen not to squander their costly investment in an educated population.. California is a national leader in embracing the potential of its newcomers, with new laws benefiting the undocumented, including a driver’s license law and one limiting local law-enforcement involvement in the federal immigration dragnet. New York City, under Mayor Bill de Blasio and Speaker Melissa Mark-Viverito of the City Council, has made much progress, too, with programs like a municipal ID card. The message: We want you here.. (New York State should be a national leader in this swelling immigrant-rights movement, but it isn’t. Modest reforms, like a bill to grant college financial aid and scholarships to the undocumented, have languished in its underachieving Legislature, thwarted by a Republican-led Senate and a governor, Andrew Cuomo, who gives the issue lip service but has other priorities.). The federal government has its own problems with coherence. It spends billions on its prison-and-deportation pipeline, yet the Homeland Security Department is not on the same page with itself. It is supposed to be using more discretion in whom it deports, but it is applying the policy erratically. A man who fits no sane definition of a threat — Max Villatoro, a Mennonite pastor in Iowa, a father of four citizen children — was. recently deported. to Honduras.. Continue reading the main story. Continue reading the main story. Meanwhile, the leader of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Sarah Saldaña, was recently asked at a congressional hearing whether she supported changing the law so that local police departments would be required to hold immigrants in custody for possible deportation beyond the time they would normally be released. “Amen,” she said, showing that she either didn’t know or didn’t accept that the Homeland Security Department actually opposes mandatory detainers. She later. issued a clarification. bringing her views in line with those of her boss, Jeh Johnson, the homeland security secretary, calling mandatory detainers “a highly counterproductive step” that would “lead to more resistance and less cooperation in our overall efforts to promote public safety.”. Depending on how the Fifth Circuit rules on the lawsuit challenging Mr. Obama’s executive actions, his valiant effort to repair some of the damage to the immigration system could well be undone, and everybody, families and felons, may get put back in the shadowy line of potential deportees. Meanwhile, the Army is expanding and fast-tracking. a program. to give citizenship to unauthorized immigrants with special language or medical skills.. Who is on the right side of this argument — the Army, Mr. Obama, Gov. Jerry Brown of California, Mr. de Blasio? Or Texas, Alabama, Arizona and the Republicans whose resistance to reform has left the nation in this mess? Those die-hard opponents fail to remember that laws and policies that deny rights and promote exclusion have been the source of shame and regret throughout American history. Integration and assimilation are the core values of a country that is in danger of forgetting itself.. A version of this editorial appears in print on April on page A26 of the. New York edition. with the headline: The Scrambled States of Immigration.. Order Reprints. Today's Paper. Subscribe. Most Emailed. How to Be Emotionally Intelligent. M.B.A. Programs That Get You Where You Want to Go. State of the Art: Apple Watch Review: Bliss, but Only After a Steep.... Well: Study Warns of Diet Supplement Dangers Kept Quiet by.... South Carolina Officer Is Charged With Murder of Walter Scott. Well: Can Orange Glasses Help You Sleep Better?. Homemade Pizza, Easier and Faster. First-Generation Students Unite. Stan Freberg, Madcap Adman and Satirist, Dies at. Op-Ed Contributor: Don’t Let Statistics Ruin Baseball. View Complete List ». Loading.... Close this overlay. Go to previous. Go to next. Loading.... Go to Home Page ». Site Index. News. World. U.S.. Politics. New York. Business. Technology. Science. Health. Sports. Education. Obituaries. Today's Paper. Corrections. Opinion. Today's Opinion. Op-Ed Columnists. Editorials. Contributing Writers. Op-Ed Contributors. Opinionator. Letters. Sunday Review. Taking Note. Room for Debate. Public Editor. Video: Opinion. Arts. Today's Arts. Art & Design. ArtsBeat. Books. Dance. Movies. Music. N.Y.C. Events Guide. Television. Theater. Video Games. Video: Arts. Living. Automobiles. Crossword. Food. Education. Fashion & Style. Health. Home & Garden. Jobs. Magazine. N.Y.C. Events Guide. Real Estate. T Magazine. Travel. Weddings & Celebrations. Listings & More. Classifieds. Tools & Services. Times Topics. Public Editor. N.Y.C. Events Guide. TV Listings. Blogs. Cartoons. Multimedia. Photography. Video. NYT Store. Times Journeys. Subscribe. Manage My Account. Subscribe. Subscribe. Times Premier. Home Delivery. Digital Subscriptions. NYT Opinion. Crossword. Email Newsletters. Alerts. Gift Subscriptions. Corporate Subscriptions. Education Rate. Mobile Applications. Replica Edition. International New York Times. The New York Times Company. Home. Search. Contact Us. Work With Us. Advertise. Your Ad Choices. Privacy. Terms of Service. Terms of Sale. Site Map. Help. Site Feedback. Subscriptions. Go to the previous story. Op-Ed Contributor. Don’t Let Statistics Ruin Baseball. Go to the next story. Africa. Americas. Asia Pacific. Europe. Middle East. At War. India Ink. Sinosphere. Education. The Upshot. Motherlode. First Draft. Elections. The Upshot. City Room. ArtsBeat. Events. DealBook. Economy. Energy. Markets. Media. Small Business. Your Money. Automobiles. DealBook. Economy. Energy. Markets. Media. Small Business. Your Money. Automobiles. Op-Ed Columnists. Editorials. Contributing Writers. Op-Ed Contributors. Opinionator. Letters. Sunday Review. Taking Note. Room for Debate. Public Editor. Cartoons. Op-Ed Columnists. Editorials. Contributing Writers. Op-Ed Contributors. Opinionator. Letters. Sunday Review. Taking Note. Room for Debate. Public Editor. Cartoons. Bits. Personal Tech. Environment. Space & Cosmos. Well. Money & Policy. Health Guide. Baseball. Basketball: College. Basketball: N.B.A.. Football: College. Football: N.F.L.. Golf. Hockey. Soccer. Tennis. Baseball. Basketball: College. Basketball: N.B.A.. Football: College. Football: N.F.L.. Golf. Hockey. Soccer. Tennis. Art & Design. ArtsBeat. Books. Dance. Movies. Music. N.Y.C. Events Guide. Television. Theater. Video Games. Art & Design. ArtsBeat. Books. Dance. Movies. Music. N.Y.C. Events Guide. Television. Theater. Video Games. Men's Style. T Magazine. On the Runway. Weddings. Men's Style. T Magazine. On the Runway. Weddings. Cooking. Restaurant Search. Cooking. Restaurant Search. Commercial Real Estate. Great Homes & Destinations. My Real Estate. U.S. & Politics. International. New York. Op-Docs. Opinion. Times Documentaries. Business. Technology. Culture. Style. Health. Food. Travel. Sports. Real Estate. Science. Women in the World. Cities for Tomorrow. Crossword. Times Premier. Today's Paper. Obituaries. Corrections. Multimedia. Photography. Classifieds. Tools & Services. Jobs. Times Topics. Blogs. NYT Store. Times Journeys. Subscribe. Manage Account. Charles M. Blow. David Brooks. Frank Bruni. Roger Cohen. Gail Collins. Ross Douthat. Maureen Dowd. Thomas L. Friedman. Nicholas Kristof. Paul Krugman. Joe Nocera. Charles M. Blow. David Brooks. Frank Bruni. Roger Cohen. Gail Collins. Ross Douthat. Maureen Dowd. Thomas L. Friedman. Nicholas Kristof. Paul Krugman. Joe Nocera. Close this modal window. My Profile. My Account. My Billing Information. My Saved Items. Log Out. Close this modal window. New!. Use your left and right arrow keys to browse articles.. Close this modal window. Edition. U.S.. International. 中文 (Chinese). Help. FAQ. Contact Us. Type Size. A. Type size small. A. Type size medium. A. Type size large. Close this modal window. Log in. To save articles or get newsletters, alerts or recommendations – all free.. Log in with Facebook. Log in with Google. OR. Email address. Clear this text input. Password. Clear this text input. Remember me. Forgot password?. Terms of Service. Privacy Policy. Log in. Don’t have an account?. Sign Up. Close this modal window. Sign up. To save articles or get newsletters, alerts or recommendations – all free.. Sign up with Facebook. Sign up with Google. OR. Email address. Clear this text input. Password. Clear this text input. Retype password. Clear this text input. By signing up, you agree to receive updates and special offers for The New York Times’s products and services. You may unsubscribe at any time.. Terms of Service. Privacy Policy. Create Account. Already have an account?. Log In. Close this modal window. campaign: inyt2014_data_element_euro -- creative: inyt2014_Euro_data_element -- page: www.nytimes.com/LandingPage/AB, targetedPage: www.nytimes.com/LandingPage/AB, position: data_country.