665
comments

Time for cops to hand over their license and registration, please | Editorial

Star-Ledger Editorial Board By Star-Ledger Editorial Board The Star-Ledger
on April 03, 2015 at 8:00 AM, updated April 03, 2015 at 5:26 PM
Reddit
Email


Across the law enforcement firmament, they are trying to come to terms with one cop causing the death of another, and while we prefer not to assign blame for the tragedy that has befallen the Linden Police Department, they might start their search for answers with this fact:

Before the Staten Island wreck at dawn on March 20, Officer Pedro Abad Jr. already had eight vehicular accidents and two DWIs busts - yet nobody did anything about it, other than allow his time in the penalty box to tick away before he got his job and license back.

His superiors gave him desk duty while his license was suspended for seven months, and for the six months his own car was outfitted with an ignition interlock. If the LPD's Internal Affairs division punished him before restoring him to patrol duty, this hasn't been disclosed. His fellow officers enabled him by climbing into his car for clubbing jaunts.

And all this happened because there is no specific rule preventing cops from keeping their careers after they're nailed for multiple DWIs.

It is especially baffling in Abad's case, since he drove one car through the wall of a supermarket in 2011; and since his 2013 accident and arrest tape exposed a young man in conspicuous need of an intervention.

This must be fixed - with legislation, if necessary.

Cops rarely, if ever, get fired over DWI. The Forfeiture of Office statute doesn't explicitly cover DWI, because it is a traffic violation and not a crime, even though in some cases discrediting one's office with multiple offenses are grounds for termination. You just can't find many prosecutors who concur.

Disciplinary policies, meanwhile, vary by town. There are DWI guidelines from the Attorney General that departments purport to follow, but Linden brass has yet to reveal how it polices its 135 uniformed officers after drunk driving episodes. In that city, off-duty cops "don't have to notify us unless they're charged with an offense," Capt. James Sarnicki said. So even if there's an accident, it doesn't trigger an IA probe.

Sen. Peter Barnes (D-Middlesex) has introduced a bill that establishes a uniform, statewide policy, and he essentially wants to take discipline away from departments with lenient Internal Affairs divisions and give them to a more scrupulous independent agency for oversight.

That's a good start, even though the Senator knows he'll face serious resistance from FOP and PBA factions.

But it would be easier, for now, just to mandate an annual review of driving and insurance records for all police personnel - which is not done in many municipalities, and only "periodically" in Linden, Sarnicki said.

Would such a policy have prevented the tragedy that struck his department, which seemed to categorize this fatal episode as a youthful mistake? Maybe, maybe not. But if someone were actually paying attention, Abad's driving record would have been red-flagged years ago, because ever since he got his license, his life has been demolition derby on a loop.

It's a small and easy thing to enforce, and if cops find it affronting, so be it: Call it a reminder that no public servant should be above the law. Police are supposed to be protecting and serving the public, not putting their lives at risk on the road.


Follow The Star-Ledger on Twitter @StarLedger and find us on Facebook.

  • FOR RENT

    Newton, NJ

    Newtonian Gardens

    1-2 Beds, 1 Bath

    More Info >

  • FOR RENT

    Belleville, NJ

    669 Joralemon Street

    Studio-3 Beds, 1 Bath

    More Info >

Reddit
Email
665 comments

 

Logger2

I don't think I ever knew anyone whose life was improved by consuming alcohol. These days, maybe two drinks a month is my limit.

ru4832000

By removing a drunk driver's license does not stop a person to stop drinking. Drunk driving requires a person to be drunk first. Our laws do not require a breathalyzer for any other offense except driving. It doesn't require a test for a person who commits domestic violence or any other crime for that test to be administered in court.


Maybe the laws are beating a dead horse here. We dont take away the ability to purchase or consume  alcohol from people who commit crimes, most while under the influence. We can take guns, passports, a drivers licence, certain jobs, even voting rights from felons or persons who commit crimes. We only restrict alcohol purchases and consumption based on if the the person is over 21.


The Alcoholism Treatment and Rehabilitation Act of 1976 said "alcoholics and intoxicated persons may not be subjected to criminal prosecution because of their consumption of alcoholic beverages, but rather should be afforded a continuum of treatment in order that they may lead normal lives as productive members of society." 



delpaso

Cops tell teenagers to never get into a car driven by a drunk yet for some reason these guys did  and tragedy happened.

TheGreatGazoo

Excuse me but I believe the officer was convicted of ONE DWI not "multiple" as you suggest.  Why is it when a police officer is accused of something the phrase "alleged" is never used but should a citizen be charged with the same offense all doubt is cast on the authorities.  I think it's time to end the double standard the NJ media have for law enforcement where it's guilty until proven innocent!

WolfeNotes

I ggota tell you I was much more reasonable and compassionate until I just looked at the photos for this editorial.


The police put on such an absurd over the top show that I am ashamed for them.

Flash_NNJ

Sorry, this editorial does NOT address the real issue:  That of fellow officers refusal to arrest a brother officer for DWI as they know these rules spell the almost certain end of a fellow officer's career or at the least upward mobility in ranks.  These "heroes", rather than fight the draconian and prohbition-like DWI laws that are extremely expensive, just ignore the law if it's one of their own as they stick it to Joe Citizen.

Cops rarely, if ever get charged with DWI, and when they do, in a suspiciously high number of cases, the paperwork is lost, the arresting officer doesn't testify, there's a procedural error during booking, etc.  It's a scam and a sham of justice. 

Add to that the obvious abuse of HGH to bulk up, and your cops wonder why we don't respect you.

TheGreatGazoo

@Flash_NNJ Rather than educate yourself on the matter you choose to swallow whatever biased information you read.  You allow the actions of a few bad apples to craft your opinion of an entire profession.  You have shown your ignorance and displayed it for all to see....and that is why you will never be respected.

froggywentacortn

Don't be a wrong way Pedro. The 3 Stooges think these guys are idiots. They knew their badges protected them most of the time from obeying traffic laws. However, the basic laws of physics do not recognize 'The Thin Blue Line" ... Thank you physics. 

Supernovs

Idk if he will ever be charged. Reports on his IG account state that he's brain dead and/or in a coma and has been moved to long term care.

NJNANNA

I believe the police dept. has to pass a mandatory law that any officer who witnesses another officer driving drunk MUST report it under penalty of being fired. This will stop the harassment of the officer by fellow officers for not being loyal . The days of covering for each other is over. Only because the days of decency and morality are over.

Lateforthesky

As a police officer this guy actually was bragging about drinking all day and night.  He knows what he did was wrong and luckily no one was killed. The Linden police department was wrong in keeping this bum. He should be fired and never serve in any public job ever.

njvet

That this drunken 27 year old mess was paid $92,000 is evidence that being a cop has little to do with education, training

njvet

Or character. He would have been fired from the military after the first incident. A sergeant with a combat action badge and a bronze star is paid about one third what boy Abad was paid.

Icehawks8

Would love to see the circumstances revealed for the rest of his accidents. I know he crashed into a telephone pole on Curtis Street in the middle of the night in Linden a few years back. You just don't do that unless your either impaired or texting

PhilRutgers

Don't forget in addition we need surprise annual drug tests for these thugs in blue, some of them are juiced up on steroids!  

idkusa

Stop hating on all the police. Had you maybe educated yourself most departments in NJ have random drug testing implemented. So to late with your great idea PhilRutgers.

Tamron Fenton

This is a sad case, This officer clearly has a Drinking Problem and caused the death of another officer, He will have to live with this for the rest of his life, Hope he gets the help he needs.

njfsu2

ashamed the blue wall protected their own to the point of allowing one to murder others (including a fellow brother in blue). shame on the system it failed all nj residents in this case.

unjust59

I think it should go across the board . A teacher is suppose educate so they should be fired for Dwi , a judge a doctor lawyer , bus driver , sanitation , ems heck why we at it any with a dwi should also lose there job .

Dooberstien

Any employer should have the dscretion. And as a NJ taxpayer I'm an employer of the people paid with tax dollars. This is the uside down part of it, and what's been forgotten - the cops work for US, not the other way around. WE are the employers, and OUR policy should be anyone who works for US is out if charged with one single DUI.

Other employers can make their own call. But I'M the employer in this issue, and that's my vote.

revrevised

@Dooberstien Good for you and those who do vote...wish everyone was a voter.....seems that Linden used some  "discretion" here which many disagree with..........

Dooberstien

Absolutely. That's where it started - Linden thinking THEY were in charge, thinking the discretion was theirs to excersize in the first place. They forgot who's who in the employer-employee dynamic.

Enuf_is_Enuf

Aaahhh, the old "you're my boss" argument.. Well let me ask you this "boss".... The next time I pull up in front of a burning building at 3am.... Should I call you for instructions before I do anything? We are" in service to the public "but you are most certainly not our boss.

northendmom

I agree. Public servants are NOT employed by the public, in PART, services are funded by tax payers, but most people really don't understand how minute their contribution towards municipal services really is.

jdelcjr

@northendmom I agree. All public employees take their orders from their superiors, not from the public. If the public sees an employee doing something wrong, they need to go through the proper channels and not attempt to take matters into their own hands. If its police, call the chief. All State owned vehicles and trucks have an 800 phone number sticker on the vehicle to call to complain and with GPS in most vehicles, your complaint would not be hard to prove. i.e. speeding, erratic driving, loafing etc.. These vehicles movements are recorded and kept for quite a while. You just need the license plate number.

JiveN Jingle

@Enuf_is_Enuf You should know how to do your job.  If you need to call your boss every time you have a task before you, maybe you should find other employment.

Dooberstien

You work for us. Your attitude is part of the problem. It's about the money. You're paid by me. I'm not paid by you.

PIMARINES2083

Since you're their boss, why don't you go up to a cop and give him some orders and see how at works out?? Give a life dude!!!

Enuf_is_Enuf

@Dooberstien So when I buy an Apple computer am I the boss of the Apple employees?  After all, I pay them.  What do you do for a living?  If I buy whatever it is you are selling (goods/services/etc) then am I your boss as well?  

idkusa

Oh and in case your interested dooberstien, being that you pay cops salary and all. You might want to read Hartzler vs city of San Jose. The police are legally not obligated to protect you.

idkusa

Lol@ dooberstien. Tomorrow when your not hiding behind your keyboard go tell a police officer what to do and that you pay his salary.

Ted2015

So what your saying is if a government employee makes a mistake, they should lose their job? Why not make it fair a cross the board and make anyone who gets a DWI lose their job, private and pubic sectors!!!!

BradleyOmar

@Dooberstien Well I'm not for one at all with cops driving drunk. However, cops are human just like you. Not the robots and cyborgs that have a one track mind and do whatever you tell them. Therefore, no matter what your profession.  There will always the human factor involved. If one person gets  fired for a DWI than everyone should suffer the same outcome no matter whet their chosen profession is. Now all of a sudden that doesn't sound too popular now,  right!?  . Part of all this misconduct i beleive is attributed to the libs and special interests groups lobbied to lower the standards with respect to hiring practices of the police all those yeas ago . This is probably a factor in most of these cases. Also, part of it is the continuing witch hunt of public servants, particularly cops, that our waste of a governor started when he was first elected. Seems everyone really hates the police these days. But the fact of the matter is everyone paints every single cop with one broad stroke just like fatty Christie did. We all know that's not a true or accurate assessment at all. But someone like you would never take that for an answer to this topic.  Bottom line is some people of the general public, which would be you. Slip through the cracks and make it through the incredibly easy hiring process and the wimpy no standards allowed, push them through police academies these days. Again, thank you libs and activist lawyers for that whole mess.. Some people just don't belong on this job. (PERIOD) Be careful for what you wish for....You just might get it!!!!!!!

amenhotep

@unjust59 Yeah, right, apparently you have a real problem with the focus being on the cops, who by the way, arrest people for the very thing that put these morons in the hospital and funeral home, yeah, sanitation workers are out setting a good, moral example for our young people cause they all aspire to ride on the back of a garbage truck emptying maggot infested, greasy grimy cans of waste, hey, I have an idea, lets take the badges from these three idiots and add them to that garbage because thats where they belong, moron!


Show More Comments